Discussion:
Is jean françois delcamp an idiot ?
(too old to reply)
jpw
2008-03-19 20:21:03 UTC
Permalink
every body knows delcamp.net

the best forum of classical guitar in the world

but who knows really jean françois delcamp ??
you can watch this :



only one people ?

oh no !

I know many people like this one

and I have this question : Is jean françois delcamp an idiot ??

who can give me an anwser ??

jpw

I beg your pardon for my poor english
I'm french, it was a cold day in southern burgundy to day
my french site on classical guitare in begining is
http://123guitare.com
I'm an old beginner (sixty)
you can find a poor video of me on you tube at 123guitare
i'ts my first message on this forum
...
Miguel de Maria
2008-03-19 21:10:43 UTC
Permalink
I can't say I like his forum's heavy handed approach.

I was playing a wedding and needed to play some religious song--asked
if anyone had an arrangement. The mods deleted my message.

At some other point, I mentioned something or other about my business
(guitar playing, that is), and it was deleted. Something about self-
promotion not being allowed.

Don't think I'll be back.
jpw
2008-03-19 21:20:17 UTC
Permalink
Post by Miguel de Maria
I can't say I like his forum's heavy handed approach.
yes I like it too
Post by Miguel de Maria
I was playing a wedding and needed to play some religious song--asked
if anyone had an arrangement. The mods deleted my message.
ok but if everybody have the same "way"
it's ok
Post by Miguel de Maria
At some other point, I mentioned something or other about my business
(guitar playing, that is), and it was deleted. Something about self-
promotion not being allowed.
oh yé
one of french luthier : michel donaday was banned
for speaking of his job

joël laplane no

no problem I like the both
and if I have to buy a guitar
these of donnadey are too expensive form me

but......................

excuse me my english is very vey poor ....

jpw
Post by Miguel de Maria
Don't think I'll be back.
dofrenzy
2008-03-19 21:12:23 UTC
Permalink
Post by jpw
every body knows delcamp.net
the best forum of classical guitar in the world
but who knows really jean françois delcamp ??
http://youtu.be/GSJb1d8QtDY
only one people ?
oh no !
I know many people like this one
and I have this question : Is jean françois delcamp an idiot ??
who can give me an anwser ??
jpw
I beg your pardon for my poor english
I'm french, it was a cold day in southern burgundy to day
my french site on classical guitare in begining ishttp://123guitare.com
I'm an old beginner (sixty)
you can find a poor video of me on you tube at 123guitare
i'ts my first message on this forum
...
Since your very first post here accuses another guitarist of being an
idiot, let me be the first to say "Bienvenue!" You're going to fit
right in here.

Nice YouTube piece.

Not only are many of us familiar with Delcamp forum, but many of us
are also aware of the "heavy-handed" moderating. I've never been a
member there myself. I hang out here, and at the CG forum at
Acousticguitar.com.
Andrew Schulman
2008-03-20 04:01:36 UTC
Permalink
Post by dofrenzy
Since your very first post here accuses another guitarist of being an
idiot, let me be the first to say "Bienvenue!" You're going to fit
right in here.
Hahahahaha!!!!!

Andresito
c***@hotmail.com
2008-03-20 15:27:17 UTC
Permalink
Pour avoir ete censuree sans motif, puis bannie sans explication par
l'administrateur du forum Delcamp quand j'ai essaye de faire savoir
aux autres membres de ce forum que censure et langue de bois en sont
les fondements, je comprend parfaitement la colere, amertume,
desillusion ou tristesse qui animent certain d'entre vous.
Cecile, ex-membres du forum Delcamp.

I have been censored without motive, then banished by the
administrator when I had try to explain the situation to the other
members. So I understand pretty well your feelings....
Cecile, ex-Delcamp's member.
t***@googlemail.com
2008-03-20 18:17:41 UTC
Permalink
Post by c***@hotmail.com
Pour avoir ete censuree sans motif, puis bannie sans explication par
l'administrateur du forum Delcamp quand j'ai essaye de faire savoir
aux autres membres de ce forum que censure et langue de bois en sont
les fondements, je comprend parfaitement la colere, amertume,
desillusion ou tristesse qui animent certain d'entre vous.
Cecile, ex-membres du forum Delcamp.
I have been censored without motive, then banished by the
administrator when I had try to explain the situation to the other
members. So I understand pretty well your feelings....
Cecile, ex-Delcamp's member.
hi cecile

you are very welcome to look at our little forum - its very relaxed!
On y parle un peut de francais http://www.earlyguitar.info/forum/
cmcanulty
2008-03-20 19:34:36 UTC
Permalink
I posted on Delcamp- for years and was at a level to download pieces
as I had posted enough. Then I get an email that he had accidentally
deleted my account. So I asked to be reinstated at the level I was at
and in return he permanently banned me.
Wollybird
2008-03-20 20:51:46 UTC
Permalink
Post by cmcanulty
I posted on Delcamp- for years and was at a level to download pieces
as I had posted enough. Then I get an email that he had accidentally
deleted my account. So I asked to be reinstated at the level I was at
and in return he permanently banned me.
He sounds more like a guitar nazi than an idiot, if you ask me.
Andrew Schulman
2008-03-21 16:25:59 UTC
Permalink
Post by Wollybird
He sounds more like a guitar nazi than an idiot, if you ask me.
Let's send him to Argentina with the Soup Nazi.

Andrew
Jez
2008-03-20 02:05:54 UTC
Permalink
Post by jpw
every body knows delcamp.net
the best forum of classical guitar in the world
but who knows really jean françois delcamp ??
http://youtu.be/GSJb1d8QtDY
Played a little slow IMHO, but keep at it.
Post by jpw
only one people ?
oh no !
I know many people like this one
and I have this question : Is jean françois delcamp an idiot ??
who can give me an anwser ??
Who cares, life's too short.
Fuck 'em.
Heads up they're arses, and all that.

Don't wear a tux, they give you acne.
--
Jez, MBA., Country Dancing and Advanced Astrology, UBS.
'Politics is the entertainment branch of industry.'-Zappa
David Raleigh Arnold
2008-03-20 03:30:59 UTC
Permalink
Post by jpw
every body knows delcamp.net
The moderators are intermediate students with very fragile egos who
don't know anything much trying to help other intermediate students who
know even less. Ask yourself what kind of person would want to be a
moderator. Censorship leads to mediocrity, and it becomes inevitable
that the blind lead the blind. That's the way it is, and that's the way
it will always be. Forget it, your time is better spent practicing.

Mediocrity is too high a price to pay for civility and politeness,
especially when so much of it comes without any sincerity at all. I
haven't been kicked out that I know of, yet, I'm just not visiting,
reading, or posting there any more. I probably will be booted now. I'm
in good company. :-) daveA
--
email: ***@cox.net (put "poisonal" anywhere in subject)
DGT: The very best technical exercises for all guitarists:
http://www.openguitar.com/dynamic.html. Original easy solos at:
http://www.openguitar.com. :::=={_o) David Raleigh Arnold
dsi1
2008-03-20 21:09:36 UTC
Permalink
Post by David Raleigh Arnold
Post by jpw
every body knows delcamp.net
The moderators are intermediate students with very fragile egos who
don't know anything much trying to help other intermediate students who
know even less. Ask yourself what kind of person would want to be a
moderator. Censorship leads to mediocrity, and it becomes inevitable
that the blind lead the blind. That's the way it is, and that's the way
it will always be. Forget it, your time is better spent practicing.
Mediocrity is too high a price to pay for civility and politeness,
especially when so much of it comes without any sincerity at all. I
haven't been kicked out that I know of, yet, I'm just not visiting,
reading, or posting there any more. I probably will be booted now. I'm
in good company. :-) daveA
I find it funny as shit that these two popular forums are polar
opposites of each other. Wish I knew what this means. Delcamp.net is the
old world and RMCG is the brave new world. Medieval vs modern. Order vs
chaos. Choose your poison, baby! :-)

david
Wollybird
2008-03-20 21:16:23 UTC
Permalink
Post by dsi1
Post by David Raleigh Arnold
Post by jpw
every body knows delcamp.net
The moderators are intermediate students with very fragile egos who
don't know anything much trying to help other intermediate students who
know even less. Ask yourself what kind of person would want to be a
moderator. Censorship leads to mediocrity, and it becomes inevitable
that the blind lead the blind. That's the way it is, and that's the way
it will always be. Forget it, your time is better spent practicing.
Mediocrity is too high a price to pay for civility and politeness,
especially when so much of it comes without any sincerity at all. I
haven't been kicked out that I know of, yet, I'm just not visiting,
reading, or posting there any more.  I probably will be booted now.  I'm
in good company.  :-)  daveA
I find it funny as shit that these two popular forums are polar
opposites of each other. Wish I knew what this means. Delcamp.net is the
old world and RMCG is the brave new world. Medieval vs modern. Order vs
chaos. Choose your poison, baby! :-)
david- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -
would you rather live in a jungle or a prision?
dsi1
2008-03-20 21:59:24 UTC
Permalink
Post by Wollybird
would you rather live in a jungle or a prision?
Glad I don't have to make the choice - he said as he skirted the question...

One of our medieval loving, absolutist-in-residence here should check
out that forum to see how things git done old-school. Hee-hee.

david
Miguel de Maria
2008-03-21 03:22:58 UTC
Permalink
Post by dsi1
Post by Wollybird
would you rather live in a jungle or a prision?
Glad I don't have to make the choice - he said as he skirted the question...
One of our medieval loving, absolutist-in-residence here should check
out that forum to see how things git done old-school. Hee-hee.
david
Good point. Delcamp is not an idiot, just a socialist.

This is the Wild West; that's France.
l***@gmail.com
2008-03-21 09:10:56 UTC
Permalink
I do personnaly know Jean-François, he is the finest man you could
meet. The idea of his forum is that people share their knowledge, and
help each other (is it a nazi idea ? you should take care of the words
you are using !!!!)
The forum, due to french laws, have rules. Subscribing to the forum
you accept the rules. What I see is that some people don't accept
rules. and then complain.
In a country (even in US) if you don't respect laws you go to jail
(even in US you could be legally killed....is it France a medieval
country and Us a modern one on this point?) Hopefully it is not the
case on a forum... There are allways complaining people, and they
shout louder than happy people. Ask all the user of Delcamp you will
find they think it is the best place to be for a guitarist.
Val (moderateur of the English Delcamp forum and proud to be ! and my
ego, dear DRA is not as big and as fragile as yours, lol)
jpw
2008-03-21 10:22:34 UTC
Permalink
Post by l***@gmail.com
I do personnaly know Jean-François, he is the finest man you could
meet. The idea of his forum is that people share their knowledge, and
help each other (is it a nazi idea ? you should take care of the words
you are using !!!!)
The forum, due to french laws, have rules. Subscribing to the forum
you accept the rules. What I see is that some people don't accept
rules. and then complain.
hello valery !

what rules I don't accept ?
please tell me
and françois holay, and cecile, and so many other people

the only people I know that not respect rules is jean françois delcamp

Unexpected, is'nt it ?
Post by l***@gmail.com
In a country (even in US) if you don't respect laws you go to jail
(even in US you could be legally killed...
I receive something like this from a "lawyer", a friend of jean françois
delcamp

I beg your pardon for my poor english

now in french :
oui tu as raison, val le forum est un bel endroit
était, car pour moi m'être fait virer 2 fois sans
avertissement je ne supporte plus
si tu trouves pourquoi j'ai été viré après plus de 1200 messages
n'hésite pas à me le faire savoir.

c'est le pourquoi de ma question sur ce forum.

merci

jpw

ps : personnellement je te remercie de m'avoir fait découvrir et aprécier le
luth
jamais je n'aurais eu l'idée de m'y intéresser si je ne t'avais pas croisé
sur ce
forum.....
Wollybird
2008-03-21 11:50:22 UTC